Critical Thinking

To Gen-Y: Part of the reason your ideas are ignored

by Andrew Swenson
image credit: Joey Gannon

image credit: Joey Gannon

Gen-Y will change the world. Right?

I mean, after all, we’re different. We’re the internet babies, we’re uber-connected and we’re ready to reinvent the system of business with blogs, Facebook, Twitter, Staction, and Yammer.

That is of course, if our ideas aren’t first crushed under the weight of 100 years of process-based enterprise thinking. Back in 2008, ZDNet asked if millennials would really reinvent IT. Larry Dignan’s answer:

If there’s any touchy feeling collision course between Millennials and business, the latter will win. Why? Ultimately these people have to get jobs–and often these jobs are at places like Johnson & Johnson and General Electric. Sorry folks you won’t be bringing your own management practices–and latest greatest Web 2.0 apps–to those places.

Although we’re seeing a greater move toward the use of social tools (“Web 2.0″) in business today, I think the point is still worth considering. It’s tough to change the way an organization thinks from the bottom up.

I may be reading into this a bit, I also sense a subtle undertone in Dignan’s answer: You can’t change anything, so don’t try.

Because after all, what reason does upper management have to listen to a whiny kid who wears a banner of entitlement pinned to his or her inflated sense of self importance?

The Real Problem

Here’s the rub: enterprise used the foothold of carefully defined processes and quality systems to get where it is today. As social business models become more clearly defined, it is evident that the rise of networks in business will spell the end of process.

Which means that as you dream of Basecamp while you plunk away on project management software that’s best viewed in Internet Explorer 6, you have a bigger issue than justifying a the benefits over the costs.

You have to sell the idea of network beyond process.

When many organizations are still asking whether or not to let their employees use social networks, the real problem is that approaching problems from an industrial standpoint is far different than approaching problems from a social standpoint.

What are you supposed to do then?

First, make sure you have good ideas. Gather support by outlining a clear plan of action. Do a cost/benefit analysis. Gather relevant articles and blog posts that support your idea. Build a prototype of what you’re proposing. In other words, work your butt off to sell it.

But also acknowledge that you are doing far more than suggesting that a few screws need to be tightened and a few cogs changed in the machine of enterprise process. You’re suggesting that we value the machine less and value networks more. For some, this is a scary shift.

So make sure that you sell the idea of network, of human interaction and connection. Troll the websites of people like Doc Searls, Project VRM, and Stowe Boyd for a more theoretical approach to social business. After all, you’re not just selling a business practice, you’re selling an idea (this is why knowing the theory is tremendously helpful).

And if it still doesn’t work out?

Then take stock of where you’re at. If your ideas aren’t implemented, then you can either stay and deal or leave and find a place that will listen to you.

But the way I feel (not advice): if you are consistently denied access to the basic tools you need to do business in the 21st Century, then I would think seriously about leaving. If you don’t have a shovel, how can you dig a hole?

What would you add? How do you go about getting your ideas implemented?

-Andrew

Image credit: Joey Gannon (brunkfordbraun on Flickr); original here (some rights reserved under Creative Commons)


Related Posts

No related posts were found, so here's a consolation prize: Simple: A Case Study.

  • http://www.theskooloflife.com/ Srinivas Rao

    Interesting thoughts overall Andrew. I've just started my new gig where I'm tasked with bringing Web 2.0 concepts into the organization and basically implementing social media marketing. Fortunately my CEO is very open minded and that was the whole reason I was brought in.

    I think that in some of the more old school companies this would be a challenge because people are set in their ways. Web 2.0 unfortunately doesn't show ROI in the way most people are used to seeing it, but it's something that can't be ignored.

    • http://wordpost.org Andrew Swenson

      Srinivas,

      I also have a very receptive CEO who has actively encouraged us to explore all areas Web 2.0.

      Thankfully, we've quickly moved past the claim that you can't measure the ROI of social web initiatives, but as you've said, we can't measure ROI in the same way we've always done it.

      How have you shifted to ROI conversation to make it more appropriate for the evaluation of Web 2.0 efforts?

  • http://www.theskooloflife.com/ Srinivas Rao

    Interesting thoughts overall Andrew. I've just started my new gig where I'm tasked with bringing Web 2.0 concepts into the organization and basically implementing social media marketing. Fortunately my CEO is very open minded and that was the whole reason I was brought in.

    I think that in some of the more old school companies this would be a challenge because people are set in their ways. Web 2.0 unfortunately doesn't show ROI in the way most people are used to seeing it, but it's something that can't be ignored.

  • http://twitter.com/sjhalestorm Scott Hale

    I really like your point of working your butt off to sell something in which you believe. There are some very traditional organizations that Gen Y will never change. Not all of Gen Y is looking to change anything – we've come through a school system teaching traditional views and that's where a lot of people feel comfortable. The few that will try to change things will have a heavy impact if they adhere to what you've posted.

    Nice post, Andrew.

    Thanks.

    • http://wordpost.org Andrew Swenson

      Thanks for commenting and for your kind words Scott.

      I agree that not all of Gen Y wants to change the way we do business. And most of the time I'm leery of making generational stereotypes (okay, so there's at least one more post on this blog about generational attributes…), but after some recent conversations I've had with colleagues who are really struggling, I wanted to share my feelings.

      Have you had any challenges with differing business approaches in your career thus far?

      • http://twitter.com/sjhalestorm Scott Hale

        I have yet to run into heavy challenges with the Gen Y approach to business (if you want to call it that :) – I've been lucky to work with people that see a change coming and want to act proactively. I have been fortunate to be surrounded with people that understand the value of getting in early and outrunning the competition.

        I don't know that we will see any fundamental changes in the way businesses work, but we may see some slight shifts to the system that years of research and testing have built.

  • http://twitter.com/RJWeiss RJ Weiss

    Very nice article. A lot of interesting concepts.

    As for me, it took about a year to get my employer, which is only about 50 people, to get started in social networking. I felt like I can really help out our agency with online marketing and after consistent pressure on decision makers, they finally made it a point of emphasis in 2010 and gave me the keys to run the project.

    • http://wordpost.org Andrew Swenson

      RJ,

      Thanks for commenting.

      A similar thing happened to me when I was working in the agency world. For me finally getting the keys to the project was both exhilarating and terrifying.

      I mean, what if I couldn't produce the results that I promised?

      I found a way though to channel all of the energy I was spending trying to sell my idea into actually carrying it through. And for a while our blog had better traffic in a week than our regular site did in a month.

      Whew.

      Best of luck to you on the project!

  • http://twitter.com/sjhalestorm Scott Hale

    I have yet to run into heavy challenges with the Gen Y approach to business (if you want to call it that :) – I've been lucky to work with people that see a change coming and want to act proactively. I have been fortunate to be surrounded with people that understand the value of getting in early and outrunning the competition.

    I don't know that we will see any fundamental changes in the way businesses work, but we may see some slight shifts to the system that years of research and testing have built.

  • http://twitter.com/beanie72 Adam Bean

    Hey Andrew

    Weight of evidence is I find the best way to get your idea across.
    People usually reject new ideas for two reasons..

    1. They don't like change, if this is the case then it is defiantly time to move to a new job.

    2. They don't understand what you are talking about, but they pretend that they do.

    You can usually pick number two very quickly by the glazed look in their eye and their constant nodding and agreeing with you.

    But if you can present them with real life case studies, and then give them a practical example of how it could be used at your work.

    The penny usually drops, if it doesn't..

    Then it's back to number one and time to move on!!!

    Cheers Adam

  • http://twitter.com/beanie72 Adam Bean

    Hey Andrew

    Weight of evidence is I find the best way to get your idea across.
    People usually reject new ideas for two reasons..

    1. They don't like change, if this is the case then it is defiantly time to move to a new job.

    2. They don't understand what you are talking about, but they pretend that they do.

    You can usually pick number two very quickly by the glazed look in their eye and their constant nodding and agreeing with you.

    But if you can present them with real life case studies, and then give them a practical example of how it could be used at your work.

    The penny usually drops, if it doesn't..

    Then it's back to number one and time to move on!!!

    Cheers Adam

  • abbyannette

    I'm reading “Generation Me” and you can bet a blog post will follow. Good stuff.

  • abbyannette

    I'm reading “Generation Me” and you can bet a blog post will follow. Good stuff.

  • http://www.karmictweets.com/ Josh

    I disagree with Dignan when he says “Sorry folks you won’t be bringing your own management practices–and latest greatest Web 2.0 apps–to those places.”

    The old guard is slowly getting rattled by the implementation of new technology tools and users who are tech savy and creative enough to start entwining them into corporate culture. Web 2.0 used properly allows us to tap into the pulse of what is going on, network, and find opportunities that the old gaurd took years to build… we can do it faster and connect with more in the same time period. There is only so much resistance you can offer when it goes against what you have been taught “should be” the proper way.

  • abbyannette

    I'm reading “Generation Me” and you can bet a blog post will follow. Good stuff.

  • http://www.karmictweets.com/ Josh

    I disagree with Dignan when he says “Sorry folks you won’t be bringing your own management practices–and latest greatest Web 2.0 apps–to those places.”

    The old guard is slowly getting rattled by the implementation of new technology tools and users who are tech savy and creative enough to start entwining them into corporate culture. Web 2.0 used properly allows us to tap into the pulse of what is going on, network, and find opportunities that the old gaurd took years to build… we can do it faster and connect with more in the same time period. There is only so much resistance you can offer when it goes against what you have been taught “should be” the proper way.

  • Pingback: Fail Fast, Fail Cheap applies to your career, too. | wordpost